Trading journal backtesting
The best backtesting starts with what your real trades are telling you.
Most journals give you a replay chart and leave you to guess what to practise. In SureInsight, Enki finds the habit costing you money in your live trades first. Then you practise the fix in free candle-by-candle replay, and see whether it works.
Free to start · No card required · Replay included on every plan
How it fits together
Find the leak. Practise the fix. Check it worked.
Backtesting on its own tests ideas. Paired with what Enki finds in your real trades, you know which idea to practise.
Enki finds the leak
Enki and the Brief look across your real trades and rank the habits costing you most. Each finding shows its sample size and the trades behind it, measured against the rest of your record.
Practise the fix in replay
Pick a market and a date. The chart plays candle by candle, from one minute to monthly, and you place trades as if it were live. Free on every plan.
See which idea is working
Tag each trade with its setup and any mistake the moment it closes. The review then compares your setups by average R and says which is working, which is not and which needs more trades.
Before you choose
What good journal backtesting looks like
Replay that hides what comes next
A backtest only means something if you could not see the result before you traded. Candle-by-candle replay shows the market as it was at that moment, then moves forward.
Trades tied to a setup
A pile of practice trades says little on its own. Tag each one with the idea you were testing, so you can compare ideas instead of totals.
An honest verdict on a small sample
A couple of good trades can be luck. The review waits for five tagged trades before calling a setup, and tells you how many more it needs.
One place for practice and the real thing
Backtesting is most useful when it starts from a weakness in your live trading. In SureInsight the journal, Enki and replay sit in the same app.
How journals compare
Backtesting and AI across popular journals
From each product’s own site and help centre, checked 30 September 2026. TradeZella has the widest set of backtest modes; SureInsight is the one that includes replay for free and starts from your own weak points.
| Journal | Backtesting | AI |
|---|---|---|
| SureInsight | Candle-by-candle replay, free on every plan | Enki finds costly habits in your real trades |
| TradeZella | Manual, automated and AI backtests; replay on Pro ($59/mo) and Ultra | Zella AI, credit-based |
| Edgewonk | A separate journal for logging backtest trades; no chart replay found | Edge Finder weekly scan |
| Tradervue | None found | None found |
Full, sourced comparisons: TradeZella, Tradervue and Edgewonk.
SureInsight’s replay does not replay your own past trades, and it has no automated strategy backtests. A good backtest result is practice, not proof: markets change, and past results do not guarantee future ones.
Common questions
Backtesting in SureInsight
Is backtesting really free?
Yes. Candle-by-candle replay is included on the free plan, along with tagging and the setup review. Free also syncs one broker account once a day; live sync on every account is Pro. Compare plans.
Can I replay my own past trades?
No. Replay is for backtesting on historical prices, not for reliving a trade you took. If replaying your own trades matters most, TradeZella offers it on its Pro and Ultra plans.
Does Enki tell me what to trade?
No. Enki reviews your own history and points to the habits worth working on. It does not give trade signals, place trades or provide investment advice.
Choosing a journal more broadly? Read our guide to trading journal software.
Start with your trades
Found the leak? Practise the fix.
Import your trades, let Enki show you what is costing you, then take it into replay. All of it starts free.
SureInsight is a read-only journal. It does not place trades or provide investment advice. Trading carries a substantial risk of loss. Read the risk disclosure.